Question for Players and Managers

[Krooner]

Something happened to me and I am interested in your views.

 

team A win a corner. As the ball is played in I see a defender from Team B pulling back a striker from Team A. As I see this the ball falls to a Team A player at the far post. He is 1 yard out and has an open goal. He misses. I didnt award the penalty but gave a goal kick. When I explained the to the Striker who was fouled that I couldnt bring it back after I had let his other player shoot he said fair enough. If it happens again should I award the penalty and face the wrath as the player scores next time ?

[SurreyLegend]

I believe that you should have pulled it back as you played advantage but can then go back and give the penalty. THe question you have to ask yourself is what would you do if both incidents happened outside the box as the penalty box should be treated no different than other parts of the pitch.

[Teflon]

If he misses from a yard what chance have they got from 12 !!!

 

You deserve getting abused either way you Kent

[NUMBER ONE]

always a very interesting situation,personally i think the play should be brought back to the original foul which of course would be a penalty, even though you allowed play to continue it was only a matter of seconds before the strike on goal.

[Krooner]

In hindsight I personally feel I should of given the penalty and I will do that from now on. If it were outside the box if I allowed a shot at goal I would never bring the ball back as the team have had their advantage.

[NUMBER ONE]

but again if its just a shot on goal its not really an advantage if the shot was seconds after the foul.

[Krooner]

If it is an unchallenged shot then my view is that it is.

[Krooner]

I have had this too. When the team sheets were brought in the manager of one side told me that they never wanted me to play the advantage. So what do I do with that ?

[Teflon]

Tell em to feck off, it's in the laws of the game and you will apply it when required

[SurreyLegend]

I agree with Teffs. Advantage is used at every level of football and should carry on being used. So if i came in and said I dont want any yellow or red cards used today would that work. Toughen up Krooner and dont let these managers scare you.

[Krooner]

Well you can guess what happened. Foul committed, I award the free kick, ball falls to striker who hammers it into the net. Team go mental. I tell them what the mangager asked and cautioned 2 of them for dissent. Would never do it again.

[Teflon]

LOL and what did the the manager say at the end of the game

[Ex EL_Gaffer]

Originally Posted By: Krooner

Something happened to me and I am interested in your views.

team A win a corner. As the ball is played in I see a defender from Team B pulling back a striker from Team A. As I see this the ball falls to a Team A player at the far post. He is 1 yard out and has an open goal. He misses. I didnt award the penalty but gave a goal kick. When I explained the to the Striker who was fouled that I couldnt bring it back after I had let his other player shoot he said fair enough. If it happens again should I award the penalty and face the wrath as the player scores next time ?

Depends if i was Team A or Team B.....obviously

[PB!]

Ha my sentimenst exactly Gaffs.

 

Ref we had Saturday loved a bit of advantage, would allow play to go on for good while and see what happened if a goal wasnt scored he would pull play back, by that time we had forgotten what the fouls were for so couldnt argue with his decision ha.

[Krooner]

Manager said nothing Teffs.

[Teflon]

Thats a shame cus you could have stuffed it right back at him

[Ex EL_Gaffer]

I thought we were all playing by mick t's rules this season anyway

[Rattled07]

A similar thing happened in the Fulham V Newcastle match last month. Alan Smith was fouled in the box and the ball rolled into the path of James Milner, the ref playing the advantage, who shot at goal but Niemi saved. The ref then blew his whistle and awarded the penalty with Joey Barton scoring and making it 1-0 in the 93rd minute - I was fuming but then a couple of days later realised it wasn't so bad as that defeat led to Sanchez being given the boot!

 

Personally I think you made the right decision...

[nut250]

you fecking fat baldy kent you got the original question spot in my view , and you deserve as much abuse as anyone can throw at you

[Gussy]

Originally Posted By: PBizzle

Ha my sentimenst exactly Gaffs.

Ref we had Saturday loved a bit of advantage, would allow play to go on for good while and see what happened if a goal wasnt scored he would pull play back, by that time we had forgotten what the fouls were for so couldnt argue with his decision ha.

What were Wembley like on Sat PB??